Dennis Prager Addresses An Evening with PragerU in Miami
By Dennis Prager
Miami, Florida
October 15, 2026
On Tuesday morning, November 12, 2024, I stepped out of the shower in my home, slipped on the finished wooden floor, fell backward, and hit my head on the side of the bathtub. The result was a catastrophic injury. I was rendered quadriplegic—paralyzed from the shoulders down. Fortunately, I sustained no brain damage.
I don't remember any of this because I was out of it for about the first two weeks. When I fell, I was taken by an ambulance to the nearest hospital in Pasadena, California. And the doctor told my wife and my son I should be given palliative care to make my end painless and peaceful. That doctor did not know Sue Prager—that man started with the wrong person!
This is how I dealt with it all from day one. I knew I had three choices: death, depression, or perseverance.
I don't want to die. I love life now as much as I've ever loved life. I really love life, and I don't want to leave my loved ones.
As for depression, that is one of the few things I fear. I've never been depressed, thank God. I've been sad—otherwise I wouldn't be human. But I don't want to be depressed.
So, I have no choice: I have to persevere. And I'm doing that in the best way I can. This is the first time I'm giving a public talk in-person, but this, I promise you, will not be the last.
Since my early teens, I have been preoccupied—even obsessed—with good and evil, and especially with the problem of unjust suffering. Many of the conclusions I reached helped prepare me intellectually, and probably even emotionally, to deal with my accident.
The proof is that I wrote most of these conclusions nearly 30 years ago in my book, Happiness Is a Serious Problem.
We can determine how we react to events. We make this determination on the basis of more than disposition. Our reaction is determined by our attitudes and perspective—or, more precisely, by our philosophy of life. Without a philosophy of life—and now I'll add, and of suffering — we do not know how to react to what life deals us.
Again, this is what I wrote nearly 30 years ago:
Most people wait until tragedy strikes before thinking about how to incorporate tragedy into their life. And then the shock is often too great to absorb into their emotional and psychological system.
Let me give you an example. Many years ago, a woman called my radio show and said, "Dennis, I just want you to know, I never agreed with you about capital punishment."
As many of you know, I am passionately pro–capital punishment for premeditated murder. She said, "And now I agree with you." So I said, "What happened? Why do you agree with me?" And then she said, "Because my brother was murdered."
Of course, I offered her my sincerest condolences. But I didn't stop there. I said, "I'm just curious: how did you deal with all the other brothers and sisters and sons and daughters who were murdered? It took your brother being murdered for you to be pro–capital punishment?" She didn't have an answer to that. She agreed with me.
That's a perfect example. Only when it hits you do you start thinking things through and dealing with them. And then it's late—it's often late.
A lot of people who were believers become atheists because they expected God to protect them. Then it didn't happen, and they lost a loved one.
Let me just tell you right now: I am not disappointed in God. I don't expect God to protect me. That is not the way I have viewed God. I want to know what God wants of me, much more than what I want of God. And that's the way I've lived my life.
In formulating my views on happiness, I have had to deal with all of the history of these issues: the Holocaust, the Gulag, Mao's starving of 60 to 80 million Chinese, Pol Pot's killing fields in Cambodia, the innumerable people enslaved and tortured, and the innumerable women raped throughout history. And those are only the victims of human evil. What about all the victims of natural suffering, such as earthquakes, diseases, plagues, the deaths of children, and all the women who died in childbirth?
This has had two effects on me. First, pre-accident, it engendered immense and constant gratitude in me. And since gratitude is the mother of happiness, I have been able to be happy.
At the same time, I always reminded myself tragedy is not confined to the other guy. I am just as likely to be “the other guy.”
Again, from what I wrote years ago:
I do not come to the subject of happiness from a particularly rosy outlook on life. On the contrary, I come to it from a largely tragic view of life. I believe that suffering is real — not, as some fine souls in the East would have it, a function of the ego, and not, as some fine souls in the West would have it, all for the best. Some suffering is a result of egocentrism, and sometimes suffering does indeed lead to positive results. But much suffering that people have had to endure is undeserved, awful, and leads to nothing positive.
Continuing from my book:
There are a number of important philosophical and emotional consequences to having such an outlook. For one thing, I walk around amazed at my good fortune, given how much unjust suffering and unhappiness there are. I am deeply grateful for, and sometimes even perplexed by, how much misery I have been spared.
I felt that every day of my life. I do not ask "Why me?" since my accident, but I did ask "Why me?" before my accident. Why am I so damn lucky? I asked that every day.
My wife is a living witness. And that luck is my wife. I guess my emotions are enough to tell you how lucky I think I am — how lucky I know I am. Among the many things I can tell you: she has crossed the country every other week for a year. That's a pain…in coach. That's a big deal. I look forward to getting back home. I love my home. My community. But I have had such luck here. I was in a hospital in Atlanta and met such extraordinary people in Atlanta who visited me. I have been very, very moved.
I continue reading from the book.
Imagine you discover a strange new lump on your body. You go to a doctor who tells you that it looks suspicious and you should have a biopsy. After waiting a week for the results, you learn that the lump is benign. That day will be one of the happiest days of your life. Why? Because on this day, you did not expect to be healthy.
Am I therefore saying that we should not expect to be healthy? Yes. We can and should desire to be healthy, and work at being healthy. But ideally, we should awaken every day and be as happy about our good health as if we had just received the wonderful news that a lump was benign.
That's how I recommend people living.
Expectations undermine the most important element of happiness, which is gratitude. When expectations are unfulfilled, they cause gratuitous pain. When they are fulfilled, they diminish gratitude, the most important element in happiness.
Right? If you expect it, why be grateful? And yes, there is a secret to happiness. It is gratitude. All happy people are grateful, and ungrateful people cannot be happy.
Forgive my entering the political realm for a moment. I hope this doesn't insult any of you — I mean that. But one of the worst features of the left is its ingratitude. It is an ungrateful philosophy of life. To live in the United States of America as an ingrate — you're a lowlife. Well, now you know Joel was right: God left the Prager in Prager.
I continue from 30 years ago:
Because gratitude is the key to happiness, anything that undermines gratitude must undermine happiness, and nothing undermines gratitude as much as expectations.
While I can take for granted that the sun will rise tomorrow, I cannot take for granted a healthy tomorrow.
Optimism has two dictionary definitions. One is the more immature one: a tendency to expect the best possible outcome. The other is to dwell on the most hopeful aspects of a situation. This definition of optimism is vitally necessary to happiness.
And that's what I'm doing now: finding whatever positives I can. And there are many.
Now, this—it was prophetic—from the book:
You cannot be happy if your primary identity is that of a victim, even if you really are one.
My identity is Dennis, not victim.
People who have chosen to regard themselves as victims cannot allow themselves to enjoy life, because enjoying life would challenge their perception of themselves as victims.
Well, I know I cannot move my legs. And worst of all, I cannot move my arms. Your arms are just so essential to quality of life. I would give anything to be able to wheel myself around, use a keyboard, hug my wife, children, grandchildren, and friends.
I've spent most of the last nearly two years trying to recover the ability to breathe without a ventilator and to regain my normal voice. I lost 80 percent of my income, while my expenses have increased significantly with my 24/7 nursing care.
Despite all that, I refuse to see myself as a victim.
One reason is: It would ensure anger and depression, negating any possibility of happiness. Another is: the effect of my seeing myself as a victim, with its concomitant anger and depression, would have on those who love me—and for that matter, all those who visit me. Instead, I regard myself in many ways as lucky, without denying any of the objective facts of my condition.
Here is one example. On virtually any given morning while I would shower upstairs, my wife, on virtually every morning, would be downstairs in the kitchen, preparing my breakfast and my lunch to take to the radio studio. On that fateful morning in November, for whatever reason, Sue was upstairs. And she actually saw me fall. She not only saved me from brain damage, she undoubtedly saved my life.
Every nurse and doctor who has treated me, from the beginning, has described it all as miraculous. And most of the doctors were irreligious, but they used the word “miraculous.” I have no brain damage, and I speak, and can breathe.
And so it's a really interesting question: Am I lucky or unlucky? I guess both—both is true. I am lucky. I’m not lucky to be paralyzed. But I am lucky to be this normal, and this energetic, and this productive, and to have the people in my life who I have: My family who loves me, my wife, and my friends—and for that matter, you. I’ve had the extremes of good luck and bad luck.
Next, from the happiness book: an equation to measure unhappiness.
U = I − R. Unhappiness equals image minus reality.
The difference between your image of your life and your reality is the amount of unhappiness you have. This is a primary reason for many midlife crises.
So, the question is: What do you do? What is the solution? Either change your reality or change your image. But you can't have a big gap between image and reality.
Consider one of the greatest musicians, greatest pianists of the late 20th century. Leon Fleisher, who at the height of his career, developed a condition that disabled his right hand. Can you imagine that? His life is his piano, and he couldn't use his right hand. So what did he do? He played everything written for the left hand. He taught. And he wrote. And he lectured.
Fleisher changed his image; he could not change his reality. That's a really good lesson.
Back to God. What’s God’s role in all of this? Should He have prevented my fall? Did He ensure Sue was almost miraculously present when I fell? Did He, as the Sovereign of the universe, for reasons we cannot know, seek my fall? Or was He not responsible for any of it and allowed it to happen? We don't know the answers to those questions.
I do not expect God to protect me from calamity. I never thought I was more worthy of saving than every one of the six million Jews, or every one of the 60 million Chinese. I'm sure I was worthier than some, but I'm sure I was less worthy than some others.
What I do believe is: God is with me at this painful time in my life. And what I do believe as well is: God chose the Jewish people. And God chose the Founders of America, who were prophets as Isaiah and Jeremiah were prophets. These were giants. They were Judeo-Christian giants. There's no such thing as Christian without Judeo. And Jesus would agree.
One more theme. I’ve said for decades: Gratitude is the mother of happiness. So, what is the role of memory in happiness? Can happy memories bring happiness, or is that not possible?
Memory is everything. It is what makes us human. If you lose your memory, you're gone. Your body is here, but you're gone. Memory is everything.
If good memories do not bring us happiness, that means whatever happened doesn't matter. Is that true? Of course that's not true. Of course good memories have to bring you happiness. Otherwise no one, except those who die in their sleep, would be able to die anything but depressed. Very few people have a happy end. But if you have a life of good memories, that's a very big help.
Gratitude is indispensable to happiness. No gratitude, no happiness. No memory, no gratitude.
But a lot of us have very selective memories—like with regard to our parents. Nobody had perfect parents. But I learned a great lesson when I divorced my son David's mom. I was in my thirties, and I went to a psychiatrist because I wanted to figure out my responsibility. The psychiatrist was a brilliant man, an elderly German Jew. Once when I was telling him about a bad memory of my parents, he listened carefully. And then he said, "Dennis, I don't know, but if we had a video camera of that event, it may not have been exactly as you described it." It was a great lesson.
Everybody has a moral bank account. Our good deeds are deposits, and our bad deeds are withdrawals. And it's worth remembering moral bank accounts—of people who you might be disappointed, or people who you might revere.
It's a very big deal to have memories, and to cherish them. These are some of the thoughts that I want to impart. Unfortunately, my condition gives me great credibility.
There was a wild bestseller that many of you will remember, written in 1981: When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Rabbi Harold Kushner, whom I knew well. He started writing it before his son died. His son, who was about 12 or so, died of an awful disease. But the fact his son died gave his book awesome credibility.
Thank God I haven't had that. And by the way, on the luck issue: when I think about my marriage, and my children and grandchildren, and friends—I hear stories. If you've heard me on the radio for decades now, I have spoken about the pandemic of adult children who don't speak to their parents. I bet 90 percent of you in this room know of somebody who has that tragedy in their life.
So am I luckier or less lucky than those people who can use their arms? Their arms are physically fine, but look at what a hole they have. My injury is obvious, but there are many injured souls walking around among us. And I am aware of that.
These are the thoughts of a man with greater credibility.