Account Login

1,804,619 Views
Apr 17, 2017
Presented by
Jake Olson

Every student with special needs deserves a good education, right? So why are so many of them stuck in public schools that can't meet their needs? Jake Olson, a blind student at USC, explains why school choice is the right choice for students with special needs.

Take the pledge for school choice! www.schoolchoicenow.com

What’s the best way to make sure special needs students have the best education possible? Support school choice programs. 

  • School choice programs have been proven to benefit students by promoting competition between schools and thus encouraging improvement and innovation. School choice programs particularly help special needs students, as demonstrated by a recent study of the McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities, which found significant improvement for students in both math and reading.View Source
  • Unfortunately, largely due to the political pressure applied by teachers’ unions, special needs students without the means to seek alternative options are often forced to accept a one-size-fits-all approach from the inflexible public school system.View Source
  • Related reading: Freedom and School Choice in American Education – eds. G Forster, C. ThompsonView Source
  • Related reading: New and Better Schools: The Supply Side of School Choice – Michael McShaneView Source
  • Related reading: Why America Needs School Choice – Jay P. GreeneView Source

Teachers’ unions continue to block school choice programs. One group they are particularly hurting are special needs students. 

  • Unfortunately, largely due to the political pressure applied by teachers’ unions, special needs students without the means to seek alternative options are often forced to accept a one-size-fits-all approach from the inflexible public school system.View Source
  • School choice programs have been proven to benefit students by promoting competition between schools and thus encouraging improvement and innovation. School choice programs particularly help special needs students, as demonstrated by a recent study of the McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities, which found significant improvement for students in both math and reading.View Source
  • Related reading: Freedom and School Choice in American Education – eds. G Forster, C. ThompsonView Source
  • Related reading: Why America Needs School Choice – Jay P. GreeneView Source
  • Related reading: Education Myths – Jay P. GreeneView Source

School choice programs are the best way to give special needs students an education designed to meet their specific needs.

  • School choice programs have been proven to benefit students by promoting competition between schools and thus encouraging improvement and innovation. School choice programs particularly help special needs students, as demonstrated by a recent study of the McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities, which found significant improvement for students in both math and reading.View Source
  • Unfortunately, largely due to the political pressure applied by teachers’ unions, special needs students without the means to seek alternative options are often forced to accept a one-size-fits-all approach from the inflexible public school system.View Source
  • Related reading: Freedom and School Choice in American Education – eds. G Forster, C. ThompsonView Source
  • Related reading: New and Better Schools: The Supply Side of School Choice – Michael McShaneView Source
  • Related reading: Education Myths – Jay P. GreeneView Source

Over 6 million students with special needs attend public schools. They should have more options for what schools they attend—not less.

  • Unfortunately, largely due to the political pressure applied by teachers unions, special needs students without the means to seek alternative options are often forced to accept a one-size-fits-all approach from the inflexible public school system.View Source
  • School choice programs have been proven to benefit students by promoting competition between schools and thus encouraging improvement and innovation. School choice programs particularly help special needs students, as demonstrated by a recent study of the McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities, which found significant improvement for students in both math and reading.View Source
  • Related reading: New and Better Schools: The Supply Side of School Choice – Michael McShaneView Source
  • Related reading: Why America Needs School Choice – Jay P. GreeneView Source
  • Related reading: Education Myths – Jay P. GreeneView Source

School vouchers have been proven to help special needs students who remain in public schools.

  • School choice programs have been proven to benefit students by promoting competition between schools and thus encouraging improvement and innovation. School choice programs particularly help special needs students, as demonstrated by a recent study of the McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities, which found significant improvement for students in both math and reading.View Source
  • Unfortunately, largely due to the political pressure applied by teachers’ unions, special needs students without the means to seek alternative options are often forced to accept a one-size-fits-all approach from the inflexible public school system.View Source
  • Related reading: Freedom and School Choice in American Education – eds. G Forster, C. ThompsonView Source
  • Related reading: New and Better Schools: The Supply Side of School Choice – Michael McShaneView Source
  • Related reading: Why America Needs School Choice – Jay P. GreeneView Source

The first thing you should know about me: I’m a very lucky guy. The second thing you should know is: I’m blind, and that’s why I’m wearing these. I was born with retinal cancer and, at ten months old, I lost my left eye. At twelve years old, I lost my right. So, why am I so lucky then? I’ll give you three reasons: I have a loving and supporting family; I play competitive golf, which I love; and I’m the long snapper for the University of Southern California, which I love even more.

But there’s another reason why I’m lucky… and that’s because, even though I’m blind, and even though I have special needs, I got a great education.  There is six and half million public school students in the United States who, like me, have special needs. Some of them have more serious disabilities than I do; some of them, less. But most aren’t as lucky as I am.

I went to Orange Lutheran, a private high school in Southern California. My school gave me a tutor that was able to help me through Calculus and other Advanced Placement courses. They gave me the same opportunities and expectations as any other student. And now, I go to a great college. But this was only possible because I was born into a family that could afford private school. In California, that’s the only way special-needs students can be assured a good education.

Why? Because in California, and in most states, if you’re a special-needs student, you don’t have any choices. If you cannot afford a private school, you are stuck -- in going to the public school that the government chooses for you. I tried that at first, but right off the bat there were problems. All the special-needs students in my district were grouped into one class. Academic ability didn’t matter; interest didn’t matter; it only mattered that you had a disability. Even if I were to outperform other students, say, in Honors Chemistry, I couldn’t take the class with them because I was blind. And this was in Orange County, California – home to some of the nation’s top public schools!

Imagine what it’s like in less fortunate communities. But, thanks to my parents, I had options. So I left the public school and went to a private one.

But what about the millions of special-needs students in middle-to-lower income families? Don’t they deserve the same opportunities that I had? Of course, they do! And that’s why I’m for school choice. With school choice, the money follows the student. Every child receives funding that their parents can direct to the school that best fits their needs: public, private, charter, even homeschool – no one is stuck in a school that doesn’t work for them.

Twelve states already employ school choice programs for special needs students. And it works.

One great example comes from Florida. The McKay Scholarship Program for Students with Disabilities gives kids the choice to attend the public school in their district, a public school in another district, or even a private school. A study by the Manhattan Institute showed marked improvement in reading and math scores for the students in the program. Not surprisingly, this program is becoming more popular. In 2009, 20,000 special-needs students enrolled. In 2015, that number had grown to over 31,000.

But instead of trying to duplicate this success, teachers’ unions, and the politicians in their pocket, cling to the old model, which benefits them – not students. In states like California, New York, and even Texas, they have managed to block school choice entirely.

But fortunately, they don’t have the final say. More and more Americans believe that special-needs students deserve a quality education.

It shouldn’t depend on whether you are lucky enough to be born into a family that can afford private school, or whether you are lucky enough to be born in the right district, or right state. It shouldn’t depend on luck at all. No one sees this more clearly than I do.

I’m Jake Olson, for Prager University.                                             

You Earned A Badge

Course: Why Special Needs Students Want School Choice

Join PragerU now to claim it

  1. Watch The Video
  2. Claim Your Badge
  3. Take the Quiz
  4. Gild Your Badge

Like what you see? Support PragerU today